In oil and gas drilling, the Authorization for Expenditure is often treated as a financial approval step. It gives the operator, partners, and stakeholders a cost estimate for the planned work before spending begins. That makes it important for capital approval, budget tracking, and commercial alignment.
The stronger way to look at an AFE is this: it should not only approve the budget. It should help test whether the drilling plan is realistic enough to execute. When the AFE is prepared with practical drilling input, it can become a useful planning tool that connects cost, scope, schedule, risk, and field execution before the rig moves.
What a drilling AFE is meant to do
SLB defines an AFE as a budgetary document, usually prepared by the operator, that lists estimated expenses for drilling a well to a specified depth, casing point, or geological objective, and then either completing or abandoning the well (SLB, n.d.). Enverus also describes an AFE as a formal cost estimate and authorization document that outlines expected capital and operational costs for proposed activities such as drilling, completions, workovers, or facilities (Enverus, 2026).
In practical terms, the AFE gives decision-makers a financial picture of the planned well. It helps stakeholders understand the scope, expected cost, timing, and level of commitment before the work begins.
The problem is that a budget can look complete on paper while still missing key execution risks. If the assumptions behind the estimate are weak, the project may enter the field with a budget that does not reflect the real conditions the drilling team is likely to face.
A low estimate is not always a controlled estimate
Every operator wants cost discipline, but cost discipline is not the same as using the lowest possible estimate. A low estimate can create confidence during approval, but it can also create problems later if it does not reflect the true drilling environment.
A drilling cost estimate should be built around the well design, expected drilling time, equipment needs, contractor inputs, logistics, pressure conditions, and likely contingency requirements. If any of those areas are underdeveloped, the AFE may not give the team a reliable view of the final well cost.
This is why an AFE should be reviewed as both a financial and operational document. The question should not only be, “Can we approve this amount?” The better question is, “Does this estimate reflect what it will actually take to deliver the well?”
The assumptions behind the AFE matter
A drilling AFE is only as strong as the assumptions behind it. If the drilling days are too optimistic, contractor costs are outdated, equipment needs are incomplete, or pressure-related uncertainty is not reflected, the estimate may create a false sense of control.
Operators and project teams should review the assumptions that drive the AFE, including:
- Expected drilling days by section
- Rig rate and service cost assumptions
- Casing, cementing, mud, bits, and directional costs
- Location preparation and construction requirements
- Pressure management considerations
- Offset well performance and lessons learned
- Weather, logistics, and access constraints
- Contingency for known uncertainty
- Completion or abandonment assumptions
- Reporting and cost tracking process during execution
These items matter because the AFE is not only about the total cost. It is about whether the team understands where the cost can move and why.
Better cost estimates start with better well planning
A well-planned drilling program gives the cost estimate a stronger foundation. Without a practical well plan, the AFE can become a spreadsheet of numbers that are not fully connected to field reality.
OSTI’s summary of a drilling cost estimation article notes that cost estimates are management tools used to determine if the well will be drilled and should be prepared together with a comprehensive AFE (Adams, 1982). This idea still matters because the cost estimate should support decision-making, not just satisfy an approval requirement.
Better well planning helps the team understand how the well design, drilling sequence, equipment plan, and expected hazards affect cost. It also helps the team identify where the AFE may need more detail before approval.
AFE review can reduce surprises before the rig moves
A proper AFE review does not have to slow the project down. Its purpose is to catch weak assumptions early, before they turn into field issues that cost more to solve.
An effective review should look at both the numbers and the logic behind the numbers. If the estimate assumes a certain number of drilling days, the team should understand why that number is reasonable. If the plan assumes certain service costs, the team should confirm whether those inputs still match current contractor pricing, availability, and scope.
AFE review should also consider whether the plan has enough operational detail to support execution. A cost line may exist for a service, but the team still needs to know whether the timing, equipment, personnel, and responsibilities are clear.
Cost uncertainty should be treated honestly
Drilling always includes uncertainty. Formation behavior, pressure response, equipment issues, weather, logistics, and service timing can all affect final cost. A stronger AFE does not pretend that uncertainty does not exist. It makes uncertainty visible enough for the team to plan around it.
AGR explains that drilling time and cost are uncertain and that stochastic approaches can help set AFE targets and allocate contingency when well conditions change (AGR, n.d.). While not every operator will use the same method, the principle is useful. A good estimate should reflect realistic uncertainty, not hide it.
This does not mean inflating the budget without reason. It means making the estimate more honest. When uncertainty is clearly understood, operators can make better decisions about contingency, contractor alignment, and field readiness.
The AFE should connect finance, engineering, and operations
One reason AFEs can fall short is that they are sometimes treated as finance documents only. In reality, a strong drilling AFE should connect finance, engineering, and operations into one working view of the well.
Finance needs to understand expected cost and exposure. Engineering needs to understand whether the well design and assumptions are technically sound. Operations needs to understand whether the plan can be executed with the people, equipment, timing, and contractors available.
When these groups review the AFE together, the document becomes more useful. It becomes a shared planning tool that helps the team understand what the project will require and where execution needs closer attention.
What a stronger AFE review should ask
A stronger AFE review does not need to be complicated. It needs to be practical, honest, and tied to the way the well will actually be drilled.
Before approving or finalizing a drilling AFE, project teams should ask:
- Does the estimate match the current drilling program?
- Are the drilling days realistic based on offset performance?
- Are contractor and service costs current?
- Have pressure risks been reviewed properly?
- Does the estimate include the right equipment and services?
- Are construction and site preparation costs complete?
- Have logistics and access constraints been considered?
- Is contingency based on real uncertainty?
- Are the biggest cost drivers clearly understood?
- Does the field team agree that the plan is practical?
These questions help turn the AFE into a more useful decision-making tool. They also help the team identify which parts of the plan need more review before the project enters execution.
The role of drilling experience in AFE preparation
A drilling AFE should not be built from numbers alone. It should include practical input from people who understand how wells are actually delivered.
Experienced drilling professionals can help identify when a cost line looks too low, when the schedule is too aggressive, when pressure conditions need more attention, or when the plan does not fully reflect field conditions. That kind of review can protect the project from avoidable surprises.
This is especially important for complex wells, high-cost wells, or projects where past wells have seen cost movement. In those cases, the AFE should not only support approval. It should help the team prepare for execution with better judgment.
A better AFE supports better accountability
Once drilling begins, the AFE can also support better tracking. If the estimate is structured clearly, the team can compare actual costs against planned costs and understand where the project is moving.
This helps project managers and operators see whether cost changes are coming from expected variation, scope change, service performance, drilling conditions, or planning gaps. That information is useful during the well, but it is also valuable after the well is complete.
A clear post-well review can help improve the next AFE. Over time, this creates a stronger feedback loop between planning, execution, and future cost estimates.
What this means before the next well
Before the next drilling program moves forward, operators should treat the AFE as more than a budget approval document. It should be reviewed as part of the well planning process, with attention to the assumptions that affect execution.
This is where practical drilling support can add value without taking over the internal team. The goal is to work with the people already responsible for the project, strengthen the estimate, challenge assumptions in a useful way, and help connect the financial plan with field reality.
BOAX supports teams across drilling management, professional engineering, project management, drilling operations, construction services, and managed pressure drilling. For operators preparing a drilling program or reviewing an AFE, that experience can help make the estimate more practical, more connected to the well plan, and more useful for execution.
Final thought
A drilling AFE should not be treated as a final number to approve and forget. It should be a practical tool that helps the team understand the cost, scope, risk, and execution requirements of the well.
The strongest AFEs are not the ones that simply look clean on paper. They are the ones built from realistic assumptions, practical drilling input, and a clear understanding of how the well will be delivered.
When the AFE is reviewed properly before the rig moves, it can help operators protect budget confidence, improve planning discipline, and support better drilling decisions from the start.
References
Adams, N. (1982). How to estimate well costs. World Oil. https://www.osti.gov/biblio/6175937
AGR. (n.d.). How to estimate drilling cost? https://agr.com/insight/how-to-estimate-drilling-cost/
Enverus. (2026, March 26). Authorization for expenditure (AFE). https://www.enverus.com/glossary/authorization-for-expenditure-afe/
SLB. (n.d.). AFE. https://glossary.slb.com/en/terms/a/afe

